MOSQUE ARCHITECTURE FOR THE BOSNIAK COMMUNITY IN EUROPE: CHALLENGES OF MODERNITY
Unique ID
ICMA-P1346
Comment
Much needed discussion but needs clarity and structure
- The paper provides a much needed discussion about the divergent paths of Mosque architecture in Europe.
- The methodogy of the paper needs to be more defined. It appears to be directed towards case study of Mosque with multi cultural and function roles serving the Bosniak community. If that’s the case more in-depth discussion about these Mosques is needed, including visuals such as photographs, plans, diagrams etc. What makes these Mosques Unique.
- Also a visualization of the imported Mosque design vs. the integrated Islamic European design would be good to further highlight and relate to the discussion.
- There is no clear overall findings and conclusion section that clearly wraps the paper. There is no title for References? The paper should follow proper academic paper structure.
Therefore, recommend with the major changes above.
Much needed discussion but needs clarity and structure
- The paper provides a much needed discussion about the divergent paths of Mosque architecture in Europe.
- The methodogy of the paper needs to be more defined. It appears to be directed towards case study of Mosque with multi cultural and function roles serving the Bosniak community. If that’s the case more in-depth discussion about these Mosques is needed, including visuals such as photographs, plans, diagrams etc. What makes these Mosques Unique.
- Also a visualization of the imported Mosque design vs. the integrated Islamic European design would be good to further highlight and relate to the discussion.
- There is no clear overall findings and conclusion section that clearly wraps the paper. There is no title for References? The paper should follow proper academic paper structure.
Therefore, recommend with the major changes above.